End the Lie

Argentinean tobacco farmers strike back against Monsanto and tobacco giants

Decrease Font Size Increase Font Size Text Size Print This Page

By End the Lie

A Roundup warning at an elementary school (Image credit: holeinthefence.net)

According to a recently filed lawsuit, Monsanto, along with American tobacco giants like Philip Morris, knowingly poisoned Argentinean tobacco farmers with pesticides which caused “devastating birth defects” in their children.

Monsanto is one of the world’s largest and most connected corporations (for an overview see “The World According to Monsanto”, with even the White House playing on their team and blocking the release of a memo from a lobbyist linked to the “big agra” giant.

Dozens of farmers and their lead counsel Ian Connor Bifferato filed the suit in the New Castle County Court, on behalf of their injured children and themselves, against Philip Morris USA, Carolina Leaf Tobacco, Monsanto, Altria Group, Universal Corporation and their affiliates and subsidiaries in Argentina.

These farmers were growing tobacco on small family-owned farms in the Misiones Province of Argentina, a rural northeastern province where most of Argentina’s tobacco is sold.

They sold their harvested tobacco to U.S. tobacco companies who requested that they use herbicides, pesticides and other Monsanto products.

Despite the distributors’ assurances that the products were safe, in reality the substance in question, Monsanto’s Roundup (a glyphosate-based herbicide) is indeed toxic to humans and animals, even more so than other glyphosate-based herbicides.

The farmers allege that the defendants “wrongfully caused the parental and infant plaintiffs to be exposed to those chemicals and substances which they both knew, or should have known, would cause the infant offspring of the parental plaintiffs to be born with devastating birth defects.”

The complaint, which weighs in at a hefty 55 pages and can be read in its entirety below, says that some of the birth defects related to the toxic substances include, “cerebral palsy, psychomotor retardation, epilepsy, spina bifida, intellectual disabilities, metabolic disorders, congenital heart defects, Down syndrome, missing fingers and blindness,” as outlined by Courthouse News.

According to the complaint, Carolina Leaf and Philip Morris used Tobacos Norte, a tobacco brokerage corporation, to purchase tobacco from the farmers and sell them supplies for production of the crops, including the herbicides and pesticides in question.

Tobacos Norte, which is also based out of Misiones, was actually created in 1984 by an Argentinean subsidiary of Carolina Leaf and Philip Morris.

It was created to produce tobacco for both the North and South American markets, according to the complaint.

According to NOSIS, Tobacos Norte deals primarily in “Support activities for crop production” with estimated invoicing ranging from 20,000,000 to 100,000,000.

The farmers allege that the tobacco companies which had been purchasing their crops asked them to switch from the native tobacco variety to a new type used in Philip Morris cigarettes which required more pesticide use.

They claim that the defendants failed to warn them of the dangers of the pesticides or even give them the proper information and protective gear while pushing for excessive use of pesticides.

Most of the farmers were using Roundup to kill the weeds and clear their tobacco fields and according to the complaint both Monsanto and Philip Morris instructed them to use the glyphosate-based toxin frequently and in quantities beyond what is required for effective weed control.

“Monsanto defendants, the Philip Morris defendants, and the Carolina Leaf defendants promoted the use of Roundup and other herbicides to tobacco farmers in Misiones even though they were on direct and explicit notice that at all relevant times farmers in Misiones, including the instant plaintiffs, lacked the necessary personal protective equipment and other safety knowledge and skills required to minimize harmful exposures to Roundup,” the complaint alleges.

“What is more, at all relevant times Tabacos Norte, the Monsanto defendants, the Philip Morris defendants, and the Carolina Leaf defendants did not recommend protective measures to farmers and their families in Misiones,” the complaint states. “In fact, aforementioned defendants actively recommended and/or required that contracted tobacco farmers, including the instant plaintiffs, purchase excessive quantities of Roundup and other pesticides.”

If this is true, it appears that these corporations were indeed working together and conspiring to make the farmers use far more than they needed without giving them the vital information and protective gear they so desperately needed.

The farmers allege that Monsanto’s pesticides actually contaminated their non-tobacco crops like fruits and vegetables, water sources, farm animals, etc. thus exposing the families even further to the toxic substances.

“The plaintiff tobacco farmers’ lack of training and instruction on the safe disposal of unused Roundup and other pesticides caused further exposure,” the complaint states. “Leftover pesticides were discarded in locations where they leached into the water supply.”

It is worth noting that, quite unfortunately, this type of contamination is not something that goes away in a week or two, meaning that the lands will likely be toxic to some degree for the foreseeable future.

The farmers allege that their exposure directly caused the birth defects of their children and that Monsanto and the tobacco companies, “motivated by a desire for unwarranted economic gain and profit,” chose to ignore all of the health risks associated with the pesticides.

The farmers are looking for both compensatory and punitive damages for negligence along with product liability, breach of warranty, ultra hazardous activity, aiding and abetting, willful and wanton misconduct and violations of Argentine laws.

Not too long ago I would have thought that this case would never have a chance but thanks to Monsanto being found guilty in France for the poisoning of a 47-year-old grain farmer, and the 270,000-person lawsuit filed by organic farmers against Monsanto, I think this case has a chance.

Hopefully these farmers will be victorious and it will be another positive step forward in the effort to stop Monsanto’s global pollution and destruction of our food supply, health and the future of our environment.

I’d love to hear your opinion, take a look at your story tips, and even your original writing if you would like to get it published. Please email me at [email protected]

Please support our work and help us start to pay contributors by doing your shopping through our Amazon link or check out some must-have products at our store.

4 Responses to Argentinean tobacco farmers strike back against Monsanto and tobacco giants

  1. Anonymous April 12, 2012 at 3:33 AM

    Yes! I’m praying that this case is successful and the children and adults who suffered because of Monsanto get the justice they deserve

  2. Lori June 29, 2012 at 7:19 AM

    I hope the tobacco farmers win this fight. I want the tobacco farmers to come back again stronger than ever before. The government has got so out of control. Telling everyone how to live their life’s. I want to see the day that all of our freedoms come back to us. We can smoke if we want to. Just want to wish the tobacco farmers good luck .

  3. Jim Corburn September 10, 2013 at 12:49 PM

    There is more to this story that would have come out in the near future if the farmers were not already fighting back. P.M. wanted their GMO tobacco and Monsanto wanted to contaminate the entire areas tobacco and take the farmers that would not comply out. This is why they wanted Roundup used. You can see many other lawsuits in the U.S. and Canada where Monsanto’s roundup was used by other farmers in the area and contaminated other growers fields, genetically modifying the crops. Monsanto then sued them and put them out of business for using their patented GMO’s because their roundup modified their crops to Monsanto’s crops.

  4. Mary Heidelman January 15, 2014 at 12:03 PM

    I hope that Monsanto looses in Argentina. The government here lets them poison everyone in the country and put family farms out of business because Monsanto is lining their pockets. The American government is a perfect example of a tyrannical government out of control. If anyone trusts them they are brainwashed beyond help.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>