End the Lie

Woman gets $250,000 settlement after being thrown to the ground, hogtied by police while pregnant

Decrease Font Size Increase Font Size Text Size Print This Page

By End the Lie

(Image credit: screenshot of YouTube video originally captured by attorney Howard Price)

(Image credit: screenshot of YouTube video originally captured by attorney Howard Price)

Tamara Gaglione was recently paid $250,000 in damages for being pulled over for talking on her cellphone, after which she was thrown to the ground and hogtied by California Highway Patrol (CHP) officers on the shoulder of a busy freeway.

This type of behavior, while indeed disgusting, is far from surprising given that police hogtying women isn’t all that rare and a woman died of suffocation last year in the back of a Los Angeles Police Department patrol car after being kicked in the genitals and forced into the vehicle.

In this case, it seems that the dashboard camera is what ultimately held the officers accountable, just as a similar camera did in the case of a 66-year-old man who was beaten for no apparent reason.

The incident occurred in August of 2011 and resulted in charges of evading and resisting arrest and driving with a suspended license, all of which were dropped after a judge saw video footage of the incident captured from a dashboard camera of a CHP cruiser.

30-year-old Gaglione, 2 months pregnant at the time, was pushed face-first into the asphalt after an officer swept her legs with a kick. Another officer used his knee to pin her to the ground, all while she was pregnant.

Howard Price, Gaglione’s attorney, told the Huffington Post that Gaglione could hear officers talking about the video of the encounter on the way to the station.

Yet when Price requested the video in order to present it as evidence in Gaglione’s criminal trial, he was told no footage of the incident existed.

“I went back to them, and I said, ‘Look, am I stupid? This involved a chase. There must be a videotape,’” Price said.

Eventually, the prosecutor finally handed over the footage from the dashboard camera of a backup officer, although that footage showed nothing.

Once Price was told the footage did, in fact, exist, he was told that no one could transfer the video to another medium.

Price was then forced to go to the CHP station himself in order to record the footage for posterity.

The video Price took of the original CHP footage being played was then uploaded to YouTube and can be seen below.

“The conduct here is outrageous. What these officers did here was bewildering to me. They knew she was pregnant,” Price told the Los Angeles Times. “She never resisted arrest.”

“After first stopping on the right shoulder, she was ordered to not stop there, to go forward and get off freeway [sic],” Price explains on his website. “Because of rush hour traffic noise, she did not hear clearly what she was directed to do.”

According to the Los Angeles Times, the officers ordered her to toss her car keys out of her window, exit her vehicle and put her hands on the car.

Instead, Gaglione simply stands outside of her vehicle staring at the CHP officers, “appearing confused,” as the Los Angeles Times puts it.

When the officers are yelling, “Turn around,” it appears that Gaglione says something, although it is inaudible.

In the official report, the CHP officers claimed that she appeared to raise her arms in a menacing manner, although it is quite hard to detect if there are any menacing arm movements from the footage.

The officers then approach Gaglione with their guns drawn, sweep her legs with a kick and push her face-first into the ground.

Another officer pins Gaglione to the ground with a knee in her back, although Price contends that it was actually placed on her neck.

“At another point, it appears the woman is kicked in her left ribs,” the Los Angeles Times notes. “Eventually she is hogtied and placed in a squad car.”

“I’d never seen a gun for real before,” Gaglione said. “I just froze. I was scared they’d shoot me.”

While Gaglione maintains that she told the officers she was pregnant when they first approached her, one of the officers, Officer Daniel Hernandez, said that she did not mention that she was pregnant until she was on the ground.

In Hernandez’s report, he said that he kneed Gaglione in an effort to distract her so that Officer Roberto Martinez, his partner, could handcuff her.

The officers wrote in their report that the incident escalated because Gaglione ignored their orders and “appeared to raise her arms in an aggressive manner after hopping out of the van,” according to the Los Angeles Times.

Gaglione later sued both the CHP, the sergeant and five officers involved in the incident, “alleging that her civil rights had been violated and that she had been subjected to excessive force and malicious prosecution,” according to the Los Angeles Times.

While CHP officials would not discuss the incident itself, they said that both sides concluded that the $250,000 settlement was in everyone’s best interest.

“The CHP conducted a review of the tactics and, as necessary, took appropriate action,” stated Fran Clader, department spokeswoman.

Both of the officers involved in the incident with Gaglione remain CHP officers.

After the misdemeanor charges were dropped, Gaglione pleaded no contest to the infraction for using a cellphone while driving.

Gaglione is now the mother of a 9-month old son and moved to Pennsylvania from Los Angeles after the 2011 encounter, according to Price, who added that her son was not apparently affected by the incident.

“I will always be scared of police officers because of these knuckleheads,” Gaglione said.

Did I forget anything or miss any errors? Would you like to make me aware of a story or subject to cover? Or perhaps you want to bring your writing to a wider audience? Feel free to contact me at [email protected] with your concerns, tips, questions, original writings, insults or just about anything that may strike your fancy.

Please support our work and help us start to pay contributors by doing your shopping through our Amazon link or check out some must-have products at our store.

11 Responses to Woman gets $250,000 settlement after being thrown to the ground, hogtied by police while pregnant

  1. Anne Barrett January 19, 2013 at 8:27 AM

    It is nice to know that America is being kept safe from mom’s driving minivans. WAIT… I AM a mom who drives a Minivan…

  2. anne January 19, 2013 at 9:07 AM

    the problem is that this is taxpayers money. the cops themselves should be liable. If that happened, you would see this crap stop.

  3. jason January 19, 2013 at 11:47 AM

    I would have happen to my wife.I personally executed these men if they had not been put in prison.

  4. Lisa January 19, 2013 at 12:57 PM

    I’m outraged that these ba$tards not only were not charged but they still have their jobs. The only thing that will change the next time they do this is that they’ll remember to disable the camera! SHAMEFUL!!

  5. BFT January 20, 2013 at 12:55 PM

    “Officer Daniel Hernandez, said that she did not mention that she was pregnant until she was on the ground” And still hog-tie her……i personally do not believe that any pregnant woman would stay calm and quiet while they are doing something like this to them.too bad she didnt get more money ,and like Anne said,it should be the cops paying not the citizens…

  6. Anonymous January 20, 2013 at 11:26 PM

    The officers, not the taxpayer, need to pay these settlements!

  7. Nora January 21, 2013 at 1:26 PM

    It’s time for new rules. These men need to be fired and go to prison for a year, instead of paying what amounts to a petty fine. Any “peace’ officer accused of this type of behavior, or patrolman or any law enforcement officer of any type, should be held personally responsible for compensating the victim of his abuse and lose his bond when the evidence clearly shows he’s done wrong. We will continue to have to put up with this crap until we wake up and take control of government. Throw these bastards in jail, California.

  8. Richard O'Brien February 18, 2013 at 2:40 PM

    We live in a POLICE STATE!!! Crime Inc is BIG BUSINESS in America. We incarcerate more of our citizens than any other country in the world. I am not afraid of violent criminals, I am afraid of the Police!!!

  9. ARIZONA March 13, 2013 at 2:26 PM

    THE CHP is the worst terrorist gang in america,and the cowards in california voted to give them their weapons,hahaha,well all you cowards are going to live to wish you hadn’t done that,they’ll come after your children next,then your property,and finaly your worthless life,you sorry cowards,no wonder you gave them your weapons,you don’t care enough to protect your women,or your children…….THE LORD said your nothing but VOMIT in his mouth,and reading this story,makes it real clear,theres nothing but garbage on the west coast anyway………..all you cowards who call your selves men “STOP IT, YOUR NOT MEN”,your nothing but rabid animals,and YOU CHP,your worse then that,your pure sewer pond scum,and I’am offened you pieces of shit are breathing my air,hopely that will change soon………………………..

  10. drew March 14, 2013 at 11:41 AM

    She should of sued for and received 100 million dollars compensation! Everyone needs to get on a jury and start changing the tide, if she would of sued for 100 million and I was on the jury I would of stood on the fact that she deserved it and should settle for no less and nothing would of changed my mind !!
    We have the power, we just need to take the time and gather the knowledge and work for the change we all want and deserve!

  11. Kenneth Miller September 15, 2013 at 8:54 PM

    No sane, civilized human being could just walk up to her and slam her like that thing did. “It” is an evil creature and should be exterminated, and sure as hell shouldn’t be out there in the streets with a gun and permission to use it. Anybody other than a cop would go to jail for that mugging. CHP: you suck!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>